Review: “An Education” (2009)

The pure miracle of “An Education,” adapted from Lynn Barber’s memoir by author Nick Hornby, who doesn’t deal in schmaltz, is that there are many missteps the film could make and does not. Thirtysomething David (Peter Sarsgaard),  wooing a teen-age girl, could come off like a leering pedophile, but he doesn’t. Jenny (Carey Mulligan, bursting with promise), the schoolgirl besotted with him, could be oversexed jailbait or a helpless victim, but she isn’t. Their tentative romance could seem indecent, even tawdry, but it doesn’t. Lone Scherfig’s “An Education” is more delicate, more understanding of the intricacies of human wants, than that.

Reflect, for a moment, on one of the film’s earliest scenes, where Jenny and David meet for the first time. An afternoon London shower has soaked her and her cello, and in swoops David, part snake in the grass and part concerned music lover. He’s worried, he quips, about her instrument, even offering to give the cello a ride. Watch her expression in these moments; Mulligan affects a curious smile, a playful but knowing one implying she not only knows David’s game but gets a little thrill from playing along. She knows she won’t be the same girl after meeting this man that she was before. There’s a spark in Mulligan’s eyes, too, that tells us “An Education” won’t be a weepy melodrama about an adult using a child but a story of two people who see in each other opportunities to get what they believe they need, or perhaps merely want.

After that first meeting, David sets about getting what he wants: Jenny. He’s good enough at courtship that there’s a slightly disquieting feeling he’s done this before, perhaps many times. (It can’t be stressed enough how perfect Sarsgaard is for this part; he exudes charm but also finds neediness in David that isn’t off-putting.) First come flowers on the doorstep that anger Jenny’s father Jack (Alfred Molina, perenially enjoyable); the ever-winsome David’s just getting warmed up. Then he shows up in their home, the picture of smoothness, able to quiet their worries about him taking Jenny to a classical concert with disarming politeness and promises his aunt will be there. It’s almost comical that Jack and Marjorie (Cara Seymour) seem less prepared for David’s charm than Jenny is, and it isn’t long before they’re approving school-night dinners in fancy restaurants and weekend jaunts with his glamorous friends Danny (Dominic Cooper) and Helen (Rosamund Pike, who deserved a Best Supporting Actress nod from the Academy). They welcome Jenny so readily it almost seems they’re re-enacting a routine. Pike in particular leaves a delicate but lasting impression. For all her furs, French perfumes and twinkling jewels, there’s a wariness in her face every time she looks at Jenny, as though Helen could speak from experience but chokes back her words. Helen might know that Jenny could be her in 15 years, and Jenny’s teacher (Olivia Williams) seems to know the dangers inherent in David’s pursuit.

Delicate, again, is the appropriate word to describe how “An Education” goes about developing Jenny and David’s relationship. Hornby’s screenplay keeps the drama to a minimum until it becomes necessary to the storyline, and even then complications — which might be explosive and messy in lesser films — are handled with care. Behind the camera, Scherfig favors close-up shots of the more serene moments, the little interactions, touches and glances that provide all the meaning we need. The director trains his camera on the actors and more specifically on Mulligan’s face and hands, finding the awkward, swan-like grace in the way she exits a car, steals a sideways glance at David or taps the ashes from her French cigarette. The camera, it’s obvious, has fallen hard for this young woman.

Only the steely-hearted could resist Mulligan’s charms, for their is much to love. Chatter about her Audrey Hepburn-ness abounds, and yet this 24-year-old emerges, at the end of “An Education,” as a true original, someone in full command of her considerable acting gifts. She keeps much to herself, but you won’t soon forget that face and those weary eyes. They’ll keep you wondering and worrying about the real damage done.

Grade: A

Advertisements

14 Responses

  1. The ending killed it a little for me. Solid effort by everyone involved though.

    • Yes, the end was a bit too neat-and-tidy, but ‘spose I can forgive that (just a little) because it didn’t ruin everything that came before it, at least not for me.

  2. Excellent review of a film I love more each time I watch it (and I’ve seen it quite often by now). So glad you liked it, I can sleep happy 🙂

    • Saw it at the cheap seats; can’t wait ’till it hits video so I can see it again! But now I’m even more mad that Sandra walked away with that Oscar. Mulligan was the clear standout.

  3. I have been championing Carey Mulligan for the Oscar since November but no one (other than The Mad Hatter) was listening. In fairness I haven’t seen The Blind Side yet, it opens here tomorrow but Sandra is going to have to go a long way for me to change my mind.

    • You didn’t miss nuffin’ — Sandy, likable as she is, can’t hold a candle to Mulligan. Nosiree.

  4. I enjoyed the film, but I thought it was a little predictable with the narrative. I knew what was going to happen that did. The performances elevated this film to be more than a May/December relationship.

    • Very true. Everybody’s all about Carey Mulligan — as well they should be — but I hope people notice how good Peter Sarsgaard is. If he’d taken a different tone, the whole film would have been different and worse. He’s so not creepy that, well, it’s actually kinda creepy!

      • I agree with you. Carey Mullian was an acting clinic in this movie. An American Peter Sarsgaard can effectively play a British man and making me forget that he’s not is something to behold.

        The director did a fantastic job with the actors.

  5. Lone Scherfig is a woman…sooo you might consider changing some of your pronouns.

    I only point this out because I care!

  6. Seeing this movie was one of the best movie going experiences I had in quite some time. That ending could have used a little bit more time to develop (although its brevity didn’t bother me too much). The acting was simply perfect. I couldn’t get enough from Peter Sarsgaard or Carey Mulligan. She inhabited the character of Jenny with so much intelligence and nuance. I simply loved this movie and cannot wait for it to arrive on Bluray.

  7. I just saw this this morning. Carey Mulligan is no doubt a standout and the cast as the whole is brilliant. However, I felt the movie was at times slightly underwhelming. The end felt rushed and too neat. Incriminating letters in the glove box?? come on writers, you can do better than that!!

    A review should be up in a couple days 😉

  8. Its a film that has a premise done before, just not as charming and authentic as this one.

  9. As I said in my review, I thought the ending was rushed and unsatisfying. To me, it was a standard coming-of-age story but well executed and wonderfully acted which makes it better than 95% of similar movies out there. Carey Mulligan was outstanding although I’m stupefied that she got so much Katharine Hepburn comparison but It was a B for me.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: