No. 46: “Lars and the Real Girl” (2008)

“Sometimes I get so lonely I forget what day it is and how to spell my name.”
~~Dagmar

Acute loneliness can drive people to extremes. It drives the quiet, mild-mannered Lars Lindstrom (Ryan Gosling) to purchase Bianca, an anatomically correct life-size doll, online and make her his real-life girlfriend. No, this is not the set-up for an elaborate joke. Lars brings Bianca into his small social circle literally: She takes a room in his childhood home, now owned by Lars’ brother Gus (Paul Schneider) and his expecting wife Karin (Emily Mortimer); she attends church regularly; she volunteers at the local hospital. And because Bianca matters to Lars, she matters to the people that love him.

It’s hard to believe that “Lars and the Real Girls,” a film in which one of the main characters is a sex doll, could be anything other than juvenile or perverse. Believe it. With “Lars and the Real Girl,” director Craig Gillespie earns a giant heaping of forgiveness for the trainwreck that was 2007′s “Mr. Woodcock.” Certainly Nancy Oliver’s tender, funny script — an homage of sorts to Frank Capra — has something to do with the change. Oliver has crafted a love story so sweet-natured that resistance is pointless. Gosling, who relishes offbeat and challenging roles, delivers a performance of tremendous subtlety and nuance. He reveals much about the fiercely private Lars through the eyes only. Gosling’s character, in his self-imposed isolation, is a heartbreaking figure: a human being who has become a shell.

Lars, as a result of his isolated and sad childhood, has become a tactophobe and a functional hermit. Although Lars holds down a full-time job and attends church, people frighten him, so he avoids them. He comes up with hundreds of ways not to touch or be touched. He makes up lame excuses to avoid get-togethers with Gus and Karin, then sits alone in his grim, chilly little apartment in their backyard. Around his coworkers – particularly Margo (Kelli Garner), who finds him cute if a bit odd – he’s twitchy and guarded. And Lars seems content with this lonesome existence until he catches his cubiclemate salivating over a website that sells life-size sex dolls. Six weeks later, Lars brings Bianca to dinner with Gus and Karen. (Their stunned reaction is the film’s most hilarious scene.) Lars has prepared a detailed history for his new love that explains her immobility and strange outfit (her wheelchair and suitcase were stolen), her muteness (she’s very shy) and her aversion to staying with Lars (she’s a missionary). Gus declares his brother “totally insane,” but local psychiatrist Dagmar (Patricia Clarkson, warm and wonderful as ever) sees Lars’ behavior as a positive step. “Bianca’s in town for a reason,” she notes, and urges them to play along. Spurred on by the no-nonsense, plainspoken Mrs. Gruner (a frank, funny Nancy Beatty), the townspeople welcome Bianca into their homes.

What’s disarming about “Lars and the Real Girl” is the way that this decision reflects not lunacy, but kindness. There’s not a scene where Oliver paints Lars as a pathetic or creepy figure, or where the script makes a joke at his expense. The film’s gentle comedy emerges from the town’s bumbling but loving attempts to accept Bianca. She’s given a “part-time job” at the mall, gets a hair cut, goes to the doctor, accompanies Lars to an after-hours party with all his coworkers — and through it all, the only chuckles come from the awkward business of pretending that a doll is a real person. The sincerity tempers the laughter somewhat in the movie’s most touching scenes, like Gillespie’s lingering, unbroken and beautiful shot of Lars frozen on the doorstep, unsure whether to join his coworker’s party. The sounds of laughter and clinking glasses make him want to flee; Bianca, however, gives him the courage to push the doorbell. “Lars and the Real Girl” is filled with small moments like this, but they build to a wrenching, strangely hopeful conclusion. Clarkson and Schneider are quietly powerful, while Gosling is nothing shy of a revelation. Even in the darkest moments, Gosling finds hope and determination in a man we believed years dead to this world.

11 Responses

  1. favorite scene = stuffed bear resuscitation :)

  2. I love this movie. I love that people fully take Bianca seriously and even pick her up to take her to events where she is signed up to be (who signed her up?!)

  3. I loved Gosling in “Blue Valentine” – I really need to see this. Though, I’d rather check out “Half Nelson” before “Lars”.

    Good review, as always.

  4. Good review! A great performance by Gosling. What made the film unique for me was how the community genuinely welcome Bianca, and accept his strange relationship, and like you say make Lars a kind person rather than creepy.
    And in that way encourages the same sort of understanding and warmth from us when we meet oddballs in real life.

    • @ Jess — I’m really impressed that all the actors kept a straight face. Although I read in one of Gosling’s interviews that he took Bianca so seriously that she simply became part of the cast!

      @ Sam — Definitely watch “Half Nelson” and “Lars.” Also, check out “The Believer” if you haven’t seen it — that’s one of my favorite Gosling roles.

      @ Chris — There are so many ways “Lars” could have gone wrong, like casting a less serious actor or making Lars the butt of “hey, you’re a weirdo!” jokes. I think it was Roger Ebert who said the film is fascinating to watch partly to see all the ways it avoids these problems. This is a movie that does everything absolutely right.

  5. Funny without ever getting distasteful, touching without getting melodramatic, I loved Lars and the Real Girl! Good review Meredith :)

  6. Absolutely one of my favourites. This is a film I always recommend to people because not a lot of people have seen it, and even if they’ve heard about it they might have misconceptions just because of the ‘blowupdoll’ synopsis.

    Made me a Gosling fan this.

  7. Like classic Capra, but without the clear schmaltzy rip-off aftertaste.

  8. So many things could have gone wrong in this movie, but they didn’t. It’s wonderful.

    • That’s what I think too — it could have been a disaster. Easily. But Ryan Gosling is so unbelievably good with the part.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 42 other followers

%d bloggers like this: