Review: “A Serious Man” (2009)

If there’s one thing the Coens love, it’s burying themes in one line of dialogue. In “No Country for Old Men,” it’s “You can’t stop what’s comin’”; in “Blood Simple,” “Down here, you’re on your own.” The backbone of “The Man Who Wasn’t There” is “The more you look the less you know.” Their latest effort, the puzzling, bleakly comic “A Serious Man,” contains the real doozy. Larry Gopnik (Michael Stuhlbarg), a physics professor, has gotten a few mean swirlies in life’s toilet. After filling a board full of indecipherable equations to explain the Uncertainty Principle, he switches to words. “It means that we can’t ever really know what’s going on,” he tells his blank-eyed students. KERBLAM goes the dynamite.

On the other hand, distilling a movie as complex and opaque as “A Serious Man” into one sentence seems a tad foolish. But there are many elements in this film, a snapshot of 1967 in the suburbs of Minneapolis, that don’t appear to make the least bit of sense: most of the characters; what they say; what they do; what they don’t do; that dimly-lit, oddball, total head-scratcher of a prologue involving an early 20th-century Jewish couple (Allen Lewis Rickman, Yelena Shmulenson) and a guest (Fyvush Finkel) the wife believes to be a dybbuk, or evil spirit, in the body of a dead neighbor. At the hub of all the confusion is Larry, a man who infuriates us by doing nothing — nothing to deserve the way people mistreat him, nothing to deserve his bad fortune and, even worse, nothing to fight it. Larry Gopnik is a man who takes things lying down. His default setting is anguished befuddlement.

Can we like a man like this?  Eh. Heroes and bad men we root for because they have courage or gumption, but the ones who live their lives as an apology? That’s a tougher sell. Still, Stuhlbarg lends Larry a kind of barely contained, Jonah-in-the-whale desperation that is understandable if not endearing. A tidal wave of despair might freeze any man. Actually, it isn’t so much a tidal wave as a flood that’s got Larry down. It starts with his wife Judith’s (Sari Lennick) announcement that she’s leaving him for his best friend Sy (Fred Melamed) and wants a gett, or Jewish divorce. His children — the whiny Sarah (Jessica McManus) and Danny (Aaron Wolff), preparing for his bar mitzvah by smoking lots of pot — don’t help matters. Neither does his loser brother Arthur (Richard Kind), a gambler with a perpetually draining sebaceous cyst who won’t get his own place. Larry’s shot at tenure may have been ruined by his lack of published work and anonymous hate mail, and then there are his feelings about a neighbor’s wife who sunbathes nude. Every breath Larry takes just fills up his lungs with more water. The film’s last scene is the gulp that might end him. It’s a lyrical yet pithy combination of Roger Deakins’ cinematography and the Coens’ faultless ear for pop music (hello, “Somebody to Love”).

Stuhlbarg, a relative unknown, is the reason why Larry curries our favor. His endless quest for an answer is often funny, but in ways that makes our guts churn. This is dark new territory for Joel and Ethan Coen — and these are the men who dream up lines like “he was alive when I buried him.” In fact, this might be their darkest film yet, maybe darker than “No Country for Old Men.” They show no mercy to Larry and make him about as pitiful as a man can get without being duct-taped naked to a flag pole. Why? Probably there isn’t an answer to this, though I’ve heard “A Serious Man” called a modern retelling of the Book of Job. Perhaps the directors simply intend to show that bad things happen to average people. When they do, we demand answers; there must be a reason and we figure we deserve to know what it is. Rabbi Nachtner (George Wyner) doesn’t think so. “We all want the answer! But Hashem* doesn’t owe us the answer. Hashem doesn’t owe us anything.” If you buy that, you’ll buy “A Serious Man.” It’s not the Coens’ best, but you can’t say it isn’t their deepest.

Grade: B+

*Hebrew for “The Name”; a term for God many Jewish people use in conversation.

18 Responses

  1. Wow, you may have enlightened me on something I wasn’t able to grasp on my own. The story of Job, even to an athiest like me, seems a plausible answer, in the same way that “O Brother, Where Art Thou?” was was a retelling of “The Odyssey”. Thanx a heap. I remember the same feeling the first time I saw “The Big Lebowski”. I left the theatre asking myself “Did I like that?” It took a few extra viewings before it really clicked for me. Not something I am willing to give just anybody, but the Brothers Coen will always get a second chance with me.

    • Amen, Ken, amen. Joel and Ethan have banked a lifetime supply of second chances with me! I think I need to see “A Serious Man” several more times, and maybe invite a couple of Jewish friends over to see if they can provide additional insight (like you, I’m not religious). But I really do think there’s something to “you can’t ever really know what’s going on” and “Hashem doesn’t owe us anything.” It’s a hard-line stance, but one — in my limited knowledge, and someone please correct me if I’m wrong — that’s in-keeping with Judaism.

  2. I have so little interest in seeing this film it is ridiculous

    • That’s too bad. It’s not exactly a knee-slapper, but it makes you think. Still, I think the Coens can do better.

  3. Outstanding review! Larry living “his life as an apology” was really the main obstacle for me. IF he would at least try to fight his fate instead of just laying down would have me empathize with him more.

    • I struggled with that too … hard to root for someone who appears to have no spine. But I spent a lot of time living MY life as an apology, so maybe I understood a little bit where Larry Gopnik was coming from.

    • If he had done so it really would’ve been a weird character arc that might’ve alienated the audience.

  4. I left the theatre after watching this and thought it was damned near perfect. But with a few months behind me, I can barely remember what the fuss was about. I’ll have to give it another go. I hated The Big Lebowski the first time I saw it…

  5. I saw this film a month or two ago. I liked it. I didn’t love it. I wonder that everybody is giving the Coens a pass because they made Fargo or No Country for Old Men.

    Larry Gopnik’s pain was the only thing that held my interest with this movie.

    • Probably they get a pass just for being Coens. I don’t agree with that. I love those chaps, but they can make bad movies like nobody’s business.

      • Like The Ladykillers, Intolerable Cruelty. People shitted on O Brother, Where Art Thou? I loved that movie.

        I guess this film would be like The Big Lebowski. You might not get it the first time, but subsequent viewing would sway you.

  6. This is really an incredibly well-written review. Bravo.

  7. This one is in my Netflix queue but it says “long wait” so not sure when I will get to see it…

  8. Not one of Coens best, but still a good one none the less.

  9. [...] Why this couple? What does all this MEAN?” Much as the Coen brothers did in the recent “A Serious Man,” Dumont causes us to confront our perceptions about how we believe films should operate and our own [...]

  10. This one was definitely not a good time for me. I found it really hard to enjoy, and the reliance on Jewish terminaollogy ultimately killed it. Deeper meanings? Maybe, but did I care? Sorry, no. Maybe next time Coens!

    • Stuhlbarg was good enough that he made me care. But I went into the film armed for the Jewish terminology — the DVD has a “Guide for Goys” that really helped me out.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 42 other followers

%d bloggers like this: